Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (2024)

By: Author Kelli Miller

Posted on - Last updated:

0 Comments

Delicious homemade candy is a traditional Christmas gift will simply never go out of style.

Listed below you will find over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes like truffles, barks, brittles, jellies and other delicious candies that would be perfect for this years gift exchange or holiday gathering.

Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (1)

Table of Contents

Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes

A Christmas staple at 3 Boys and a Dog is Irish Potato Candy. My great-grandmother made it, my grandmother, my mom, and now me! It is super sweet, so just a couple pieces at a time is more than enough.

ThisOreo Barkfrom Cookilicious is sure to be a crowd pleaser! I bet it would be great with the vanilla OREO cookies as well!

Toted as “simply irresistible, thisSaltine Toffeefrom Suburban Simplicity is right up my alley! I love sweet and salty in one bite!

Blossom to Stem makes some super yummy soundingPassion Fruit Jellies.

Another yummy toffee recipe! ThisChocolate Toffeeis from The Gracious Wife. The name, though, makes me aware of my shortcomings! I am not very gracious. I should work on that!

My 17 year old likes Rocky Road Ice Cream. I just bet he would LOVE thisRocky Road Clusterfrom Kleinworth Co!

Oh my word! I love Reese’s, but they have gotten so expensive! TheseJumbo Peanut Butter Cupsfrom Wake up to Waffles is on my to try list now!

Why is brittle such a yummy candy? While I am a big fan of Peanut Brittle, I can’t resist thisChocolate Chip Cookie Brittlefrom The Modern Proper!

The soft chocolate exterior of these Toffee Pecan Chocolate Trufflesfrom Sugar Salt Magic, gives way to perfectly crispy sweet pecans.

I love how the Sweetest Menu describes herCherry Cashew Chocolate Bark:Roasted salted cashew nuts and freeze-dried cherries are scattered over a bed of melted dark chocolate with white chocolate swirls. Well now, that sounds UH-MAy-ZING, right!?

Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (2)

Another favorite Christmas Candy in the 3 Boys and a Dog household, is another family recipe… Spiced Pecans. So stinking yummy!

Love this recipe and video from Rice and Flour! I have always wondered how to makeGumdrop Candy.

You just thought the salted caramel was the secret ingredient in theseCaramel Peanut Butter Cupsfrom Sweetest Kitchen. Nope, it is not!

TheseOrange and Cranberry Jelliesfrom The Healthy Foodie look pretty, but the best part is that they are fairly healthy.

Low Carb and Sugar Free!? How can theseCaramel Nut Clusters from Tasteaholics be so darn good?

TheseChocolate Peanut Butter Toffee Crackersfrom Snappy Gourmet are actually called Crack Bars – because they are so addictive. 🙂

Cashews are my most favorite nut. They are smooth!I especially love them in brittle like theseCandied Cashewsfrom East Van Vegan.

This is a recurring theme here since my oldest boy is a junk-food-junkie like his Momma. But, he really loves Almond Joy candies. COnsequently, I can’t wait for him to try theseAlmond Joy Cupsfrom The Big Man’s World.

This is the creamiest fudge recipe around. Seriously, try this Fantasy Fudge from 3BD!

Be sure to check out this Guide to Traditional Southern Candies!

Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (3)

More Christmas Candy Recipes:

Below, you will find even more delicious candies that you can make for Christmas. Be sure to share them with friends, family, neighbors, and your delivery folks!

Chocolate and Cashew Butter Bark

Maple Toffee

Caramel Apple Popcorn

Peanut Butter Pretzel Cups

Buckeyes

Strawberry Truffles

Coconut Agar-Agar Jellies

Double Chocolate Fudge

Peanut Brittle

Salty Popped Amaranth Bark

Carrot Cake Truffles

Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (4)

I learned this Cool Mint OREO Truffles recipe at Kraft Kitchens and was able to share it with you. 🙂

Peppermint Chocolate Bites

Candy Cane Chocolate Truffles

Sesame Cashew Brittle

Salted Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Brownie Batter Bark

Sugar Plum Gumdrops

Rocky Road Fudge

Brownie Brittle

Peppermintmellows

Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (5)

Another fun and delicious recipe learned at Kraft Kitchen: Chocolate Bacon Crunch. Don’t knock it until you try it!

Mint Chocolate Truffles

Chocolate Pretzel Fudge

Butterscotch Swirl Bark

Gingersnap Cookie Dough Truffles

Banana Chocolate Fudge

Salted Maple Walnut Brittle

Peanut Butter Chocolate Swirl Bark

Chocolate Covered Peppermint Popcorn

Chai Spice Pecan Brittle

Microwavable Peanut Butter Brittle

Do you have a favorite traditional Christmas candy recipe?

Candy Making Resources:

When making christmas candy, you need to share it! Plus, you really need to have the necessary ingredients from a double boiler to the right thermometer. The following items are recommended by me and are available on Amazon (aff links).

Over 50 Traditional Christmas Candy Recipes (2024)

FAQs

What is the oldest Christmas candy? ›

One of the oldest traditional candies eaten for special occasions like Christmas is marzipan. This almond-based confection dates back centuries, with origins in Asia, the Middle East, and Europe. Each region has its own uses for the sweet.

How far in advance can you make Christmas candy? ›

Most candies will keep 2 to 3 weeks (if not longer) if stored tightly covered in a cool, dry place or in the refrigerator. It's best to avoid storing different types of candy together in the same container because hard candies will become soft and sticky, and soft candies will dry out.

What is the least popular Christmas candy? ›

These Are the Most Hated Christmas Candies in America, and the List Will Make You Furious
  1. Reindeer Corn. Walmart/Allrecipes.
  2. Christmas Nougat. Walmart/Allrecipes. ...
  3. Chocolate-Covered Cherry Cordials. Walmart/Allrecipes. ...
  4. Candy Canes (Non-Peppermint) ...
  5. Peeps. ...
  6. Ribbon Candy. ...
  7. Old-Fashioned Hard Candies. ...
  8. Lifesavers Storybooks. ...
Dec 11, 2023

What is the number one sold candy in the world? ›

Most popular candy of all time is Reese's peanut butter cups. followed by skittles then M&Ms in the USA at least . Around the world it's snickers. Reeses owned by the Hershey company was the top selling snack sized candy sold 172 million dollars worth in 2017.

What happens to unsold Christmas candy? ›

"All but a very small portion is sold, the rest may go to a food pantry like Second Harvest. But every retailer has to deal with their own leftover inventory on their own."

What Christmas candy won't melt? ›

Candies such as Lemonheads, Red Hots, and Atomic Fireballs are each individually wrapped, which creates a barrier and protects the candy from the hot temperatures outside. And, because pan candy is on the harder side itself, it's less likely to melt when you take it out of its packaging.

What candy takes the longest to expire? ›

Candy Shelf Life Guidelines:
  • Bubblegum: two months.
  • Candy Bars: one month.
  • Candy Corn: two months.
  • Caramel: 12 months.
  • Concession Candy: one month.
  • Dark Chocolate: two months.
  • Gummy Candy: 12 months.
  • Hard Candy: 12 months.

What is the number one candy holiday? ›

Trumped by Halloween, Easter is known as the second best-selling candy holiday in the nation. Americans spend an average of $2 billion on Halloween candy, $1.9 billion on Easter candy, $1.4 billion on Christmas candy and $1 billion on Valentine's Day candy.

What is the best Christmas fruit? ›

In My Fruit Bowl, I Would Buy:
  • Lychee: Beautiful Mauritius from Southern Africa.
  • Clementines: Tacle from Italy, Clemenules from Spain.
  • Grapes: Sable, Sweet Celebration, Sugar Crisp, Sweet Globe.
  • Persimmons: Spanish Rojo Brilliante.
  • Blueberries & Raspberries:
  • Apples: Rubens, Envy, Kanzi.
  • Pears: Concorde, Comice.

What is the most eaten thing on Christmas? ›

Nationally, these are the most popular Christmas foods in America:
  • Roasted potatoes (91%)
  • Scalloped potatoes (83%)
  • Roast beef (77%)
  • Red velvet cake (76%)
  • Ham (76%)
  • Christmas nuts (76%)
Aug 1, 2023

What is sold the most at Christmas? ›

Toys are always top sellers during Christmas as people buy gifts for children. Popular toys often sell out quickly during the holidays. Gift Cards - Gift cards to popular retail chains, restaurants, and entertainment services are one of the most purchased items.

What is the biggest candy consuming holiday? ›

While Halloween may be the most popular holiday for candy sales, other holidays also have a significant impact on the consumption of sweet treats. Easter, Valentine's Day, and even Independence Day all drive people to purchase candy to celebrate with loved ones or enjoy on their own.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 5908

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.